Are carrots starchy? Read What Experts Say!

Carrot is a root vegetable that is considered one of the healthiest things to eat on the planet. It’s crunchy, a little sweet, and loaded with beneficial nutrients. Vitamin A, K, fiber, and minerals, are all abundant in carrots. 

But there are some people who think carrots are unhealthy to eat due to their starchy content. Starch can be good or bad, depending upon how much you are consuming.

So, Are carrots starchy?

Carrots contain very little starch. That is why there is confusion. Some people still call them non-starchy, while others have decided that carrots are starchy.

Want to know more to clear things up? Then continue reading.

Difference between starchy and non-starchy vegetables

Are carrots starchy

First, you should know the difference between starchy and non-starchy vegetables. This is will help you to understand whether carrots are starchy or not. 

Consuming a lot of fruits and vegetables is good for your health and longevity. So, eating vegetables is super important for staying healthy. But, you must have heard that starchy vegetables are high in carbohydrates. So, you should avoid them. 

Let’s compare both starch and non-starchy vegetable to know the truth. 

Starchy vegetable

Starch is the type of carbohydrate that we consume in the form of daily food we eat. The carbohydrate starch is broken down by your body into glucose. 

The calories in starchy veggies are more than those in non-starchy vegetables. They also contain less fiber, so you will feel hungry after some time. 

Still, health professionals recommend keeping them to roughly a quarter of your plate. Because starchy veggies contain more carbohydrates, they might produce a blood sugar increase. 

Some starchy vegetables include white potatoes, corn, Sweet potatoes, and peas.

Non-starchy vegetables:

Non-starchy vegetables (olives, carrots, cabbages, Brussels, and sprouts) contain more fiber and less quantity of sugar than starchy vegetables. Per serving, they generally contain roughly 5 grams of carbs. Also, Antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals are abundant in non-starchy vegetables. 

So, it is the best option if you want to take fewer calories and starch. By eating non-starchy food your overall health improves and there is no risk of weight gain as well. 

Take a look at the comparison below:

ComponentsStarchy vegetablesNon-starchy vegetables
NutrientsPresent in High quantityRich in nutrients
CaloriesHigh proportion of caloriesComparatively low calories
ProteinRich in proteinPoor in protein
StarchHigh amount of starchLow amount of starch

Are carrots starchy or not starchy? Deciding the debate

are carrots a starchy vegetable

The question generally asked is, are carrots a starchy vegetable? And are carrots a starch or a vegetable?  Well, to your surprise, no. Carrots are widely regarded as non-starchy “vegetables”, and not fruits, due to their low starch content.

However, other specialists say that it is a starchy vegetable because it contains some levels of starch.

Actually, both are correct because carrots do contain some starch but not that much to call them “a starchy vegetable”.

Let us explain in detail.

Carrots do have some starch in them. But the amount is so small that it causes no harm (One large carrot has 1.5 grams of starch).

Most plants, including fruits, vegetables, and grains, contain starch, which is a carbohydrate. Starchy foods are very important because they provide energy, fiber, a feeling of fullness, and a well-balanced diet. 

Starch molecules are broken down by the body into glucose, which is the body’s prime fuel source. But, taking too much starch may increase glucose levels in the body which can cause extreme harm to a diabetic patient.

The sigh of relief is that Carrots are well known as non-starchy vegetables because of their little starch.

According to Nutrition & Dietetics Academy, “Carrots are non-starchy vegetables and can cause no harm. You can make it a part of your balanced diet since the amount of carbs in them is very small.”

But you should stay away from carrot cake or any other sugar-rich dessert.

Long story short,  are carrots high in starch? No. The amount is so low that experts consider it non-starchy.

Let’s take a look at the nutritional content of raw carrot:

Nutrients in one carrotQuantity
Fiber1.7g
carbohydrates5.8g
Calories25g
Calcium20.1mg
Starch1.5g

As you can see in the table above, the starch content of carrots is not that much. Hence, it is regarded as a non-starchy vegetable.

Now, let’s find out the amount of starch in different conditions.

CarrotAmount of starch
Frozen salted carrot0.31g
Unsalted frozen carrot0.31g
Cooked carrot0.17g
Raw baby carrot0 gram

Are starchy vegetables bad for health?

Are starchy vegetables bad for health

Actually, vegetables with a high carbohydrate content get a bad reputation. As a result, the world has shied away from carbs in any form. People consider starchy food “unhealthy” due to the presence of high calories.

But, that’s not completely true.

Our body needs starch in some form to convert it into glucose.  Glucose is crucial to carry out chemical processes.

Glucose, which comes from starch, is very important as it acts as energy fuel. Without glucose, organs won’t have any energy to work. That is why you also feel low when the glucose levels are down.

Hence, we recommend including starch in your meal. 

Starchy vegetables, such as potatoes and maize (grains that many people mistake for vegetables), are now being proposed as being helpful to your health by nutrition experts. 

They’re high in potassium and a great source of nutritious carbohydrates. So, it is good for those who want to gain muscles. Such people need to intake more calories and starchy foods can help them.

However, instead of strucking off starchy vegetables from your diet plan, try eating them in moderation and follow smart cooking methods. If you still find that they elevate your sugar levels or hinder you from losing weight, cut down on the serving size.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Which vegetables do not contain starch?

Green Leafy Vegetables, such as lettuce, spinach, cabbage, and watercress contain minimal starch content. Similarly, Calciferous vegetables, such as mustard greens, arugula, cauliflower, artichoke, collard greens, and broccoli, are thought to be particularly healthy as they have less starch in them.

Are there any Health Benefits of carrots?

They’re a healthy weight-loss snack that decreases cholesterol, boosts the immune system, and better eye health. Furthermore, the antioxidants in this vegetable can kill free radicals, the primary culprit of spreading cancer cells. 

What happens if I eat too many carrots?

It is not life-threatening, but still it is better not to over-eat this vegetable. Eating many carrots regularly can cause an accumulation of beta carotene in the body. As a result, skin discoloration occurs. 

Final Words

So, are carrots starchy?

Consuming a lot of fruits and vegetables is good for your health and longevity, Carrots can be categorized as both starchy and non-starchy vegetables. 

Carrots are considered non-starchy, due to their less starch content. Similarly, they are starchy because of the presence of a small amount of starch.

 A consultation with experts may also be beneficial if portion control is not helping you in weight loss. They can develop a diet plan for you based on your nutritional requirements and general health.

Muneeb Haider

Muneeb Haider

Hi, I am Syed Muneeb Haider. I have been writing articles on health, fitness, and nutrition for over half a decade. Since Writing about these topics can change people's lives, I always find it satisfying that I am contributing to making society better in some capacity.

Wholesomealive.com -a blog about Healthy Living
Logo